PUBLICATION ETHICS
Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement
1. Ethical Principles
This journal is committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics, academic integrity, transparency, and accountability. All parties involved in the publication process, including authors, editors, peer reviewers, and the publisher, are required to uphold ethical principles and professional standards in scholarly publishing.
The journal adheres to internationally recognized publication ethics principles, including the guidelines and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, duplicate publication, improper authorship, citation manipulation, and other forms of publication misconduct are strictly prohibited.
Editorial decisions must be based on the scholarly quality, originality, relevance, methodological rigor, and contribution of a manuscript. The journal ensures that all manuscripts are evaluated fairly and objectively, without discrimination based on the authors' personal characteristics, institutional affiliations, nationality, or other irrelevant considerations.
2. Ethical Responsibilities of Authors
Authors are responsible for ensuring that their manuscripts comply with the journal's publication ethics requirements.
2.1. Originality and Plagiarism
Authors must submit original manuscripts that have not been published previously and are not under consideration by another journal. All sources, ideas, quotations, data, and materials obtained from other works must be properly acknowledged and cited. Plagiarism, including self-plagiarism and the unauthorized reuse of previously published material, is prohibited.
2.2. Authorship and Contributions
Authorship must be limited to individuals who have made substantial scholarly contributions to the research, manuscript preparation, analysis, or interpretation. All authors must approve the final manuscript and agree to its submission. Individuals who do not meet the criteria for authorship should be acknowledged appropriately.
2.3. Research Integrity
Authors must report their research methods, data, findings, and conclusions accurately and honestly. Fabrication, falsification, manipulation of research results, and misleading reporting are prohibited. Authors must be prepared to provide relevant supporting data or documentation when reasonably requested by the editor.
2.4. Research Ethics and Informed Consent
Research involving human participants, personal data, or other ethically sensitive materials must comply with applicable ethical standards and institutional requirements. Where required, authors must obtain approval from an authorized research ethics committee and informed consent from participants. Ethical approval, consent procedures, and permissions to publish identifiable information must be reported appropriately.
2.5. Conflicts of Interest and Funding
Authors must disclose any financial, professional, institutional, or personal relationships that could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, their research. All relevant funding sources must be acknowledged.
2.6. Duplicate Submission and Publication
Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals. Substantial overlap with previously published or submitted work must be disclosed to the editor. Any reuse of previously published material must be properly cited and, where necessary, authorized by the copyright holder.
3. Policy on the Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) by Authors
The journal recognizes that generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools may assist authors in certain aspects of academic writing. However, AI must not replace the intellectual contribution, critical judgment, or scholarly responsibility of the authors.
3.1. Permitted Uses of AI
Authors may use AI-assisted tools for limited purposes, including language editing, grammar correction, translation, formatting assistance, and preliminary organization of ideas, provided that such use does not compromise the originality, accuracy, confidentiality, or integrity of the research.
3.2. Disclosure of AI Use
Authors must disclose any substantive use of generative AI in preparing their manuscripts, particularly when AI is used to generate or substantially revise scholarly text, develop analytical arguments, synthesize literature, or produce research-related content. The disclosure must identify the AI tool used and explain its purpose.
The disclosure should be included in a separate section entitled "Declaration of Generative AI Use" or in another section specified by the journal. Routine spelling, grammar, and formatting assistance may be exempt from disclosure when permitted by the journal.
3.3. Prohibited Uses of AI
Authors must not use AI to fabricate or falsify research data, invent references, generate false evidence, misrepresent research findings, conceal plagiarism, or create misleading representations of research activities. AI-generated citations and factual claims must be independently verified against reliable original sources.
AI tools must not be listed as authors because they cannot assume responsibility for the integrity and accuracy of scholarly work.
3.4. Author Accountability
Authors remain fully responsible for every part of their submitted manuscripts, including content generated or modified using AI. They must verify the accuracy of all information, references, interpretations, and conclusions and ensure compliance with copyright, confidentiality, and research ethics requirements.
Failure to disclose substantive AI use, or the use of AI to facilitate research or publication misconduct, may result in manuscript rejection, a request for correction, retraction of a published article, or other appropriate action.
4. Strict Prohibition of AI Use by Peer Reviewers
The journal requires peer reviewers to conduct manuscript evaluations independently, personally, and exclusively through their own scholarly expertise and professional judgment. The use of artificial intelligence (AI) by peer reviewers to conduct, assist with, or influence the peer-review process is strictly prohibited.
4.1. Prohibition of AI-Assisted Reviewing
Peer reviewers must not use generative AI tools or AI-powered systems to perform any part of the review process. This prohibition includes, but is not limited to:
-
Uploading or submitting a manuscript, in whole or in part, to any AI tool or platform for analysis, evaluation, or summarization.
-
Using AI to assess a manuscript's originality, methodology, theoretical framework, research findings, arguments, or conclusions.
-
Using AI to generate, draft, rewrite, summarize, translate, or improve reviewer comments and evaluation reports.
-
Using AI to formulate recommendations concerning manuscript acceptance, revision, or rejection.
-
Using AI to identify research weaknesses, methodological errors, missing references, plagiarism, or potential research misconduct as part of the review assessment.
-
Using AI agents, automated reviewing services, or other AI-based systems to perform or delegate any substantive part of the assigned review.
Peer reviewers must prepare their evaluation reports independently, based on their own expertise, critical analysis, and direct examination of the manuscript.
4.2. Protection of Confidentiality
Manuscripts submitted for peer review are confidential scholarly documents. Reviewers must not upload, transmit, or disclose manuscript content, unpublished data, reviewer reports, or editorial communications to AI systems or external services for review-related purposes.
4.3. Declaration of Compliance
By accepting a review assignment, reviewers confirm that they will conduct the review independently and will not use AI to perform, assist with, or generate any part of their evaluation. The journal may request confirmation of compliance when necessary.
4.4. Consequences of Violations
Any reviewer found to have used AI in violation of this policy may be removed from the review assignment, and the review report may be excluded from the editorial decision-making process. Depending on the circumstances and severity of the violation, the journal may decline future review assignments from the individual concerned and take other appropriate measures.
Reviewers must immediately inform the editor if they have inadvertently disclosed confidential manuscript material to an AI system or otherwise breached this policy.
5. Ethical Responsibilities of Editors
Editors are responsible for ensuring that manuscripts are processed fairly, confidentially, and in accordance with the journal's ethical standards.
5.1. Fair Editorial Decisions
Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly merit, originality, methodological quality, relevance, and compliance with the journal's scope and policies.
5.2. Confidentiality
Editors must protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts, reviewer identities where applicable, reviewer reports, and editorial correspondence. Confidential manuscript content must not be uploaded to AI systems or third-party platforms without appropriate authorization and safeguards.
5.3. Conflicts of Interest
Editors must disclose and appropriately manage any actual or potential conflicts of interest. An editor with a relevant conflict must not participate in the evaluation or decision-making process for the manuscript concerned.
5.4. Reviewer Selection and Oversight
Editors must appoint qualified reviewers with relevant expertise and communicate the journal's strict prohibition on AI-assisted peer review. Editors must assess reviewer reports for relevance, scholarly substance, and compliance with the journal's policies.
5.5. Ethical Investigations
Editors must investigate credible allegations of plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, improper authorship, undisclosed AI use, or other ethical violations. Investigations must be conducted fairly, confidentially, and proportionately.
6. Ethical Responsibilities of the Publisher
The publisher must support editorial independence, protect the integrity of the publication process, and provide appropriate administrative and technical support for ethical publishing practices.
The publisher must not improperly influence editorial decisions for financial, commercial, institutional, or personal reasons. Publication fees, where applicable, must not determine or influence the outcome of peer review.
The publisher and editorial team share responsibility for maintaining transparent policies, addressing publication misconduct, and correcting the scholarly record when necessary.
7. Peer-Review Integrity
The journal applies a rigorous peer-review process to maintain the quality and credibility of published research. Manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening before being assigned to qualified independent reviewers.
The journal applies a [double-blind/single-blind] peer-review system, as specified in its peer-review policy. Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based assessments. The final decision concerning publication rests with the editor.
The journal prohibits fabricated review reports, manipulation of reviewer identities, coercive citation practices, unauthorized disclosure of manuscripts, and AI-assisted peer review.
8. Publication Misconduct and Sanctions
Publication misconduct includes, but is not limited to:
-
Plagiarism and unauthorized reuse of published or unpublished material.
-
Fabrication or falsification of data and research findings.
-
Duplicate publication or simultaneous submission.
-
Improper authorship and undisclosed conflicts of interest.
-
Citation manipulation and peer-review manipulation.
-
Breaches of confidentiality and research ethics.
-
Undisclosed or prohibited use of AI.
-
The use of AI by peer reviewers to evaluate manuscripts or prepare review reports.
When an ethical violation is suspected, the journal will examine the available evidence and, where appropriate, provide the relevant parties with an opportunity to respond. Depending on the seriousness of the violation, the journal may reject a manuscript, request corrections, exclude a review report, reassign a reviewer, issue a correction or retraction, publish an expression of concern, or notify the relevant institution when justified.
All decisions will be made proportionately and in accordance with recognized publication ethics principles.
9. Corrections, Retractions, and Post-Publication Concerns
The journal is committed to preserving the accuracy and reliability of the scholarly record. Corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern may be issued when credible evidence indicates substantial errors, unreliable findings, or serious ethical violations.
Authors are expected to cooperate with the editorial team in correcting significant errors. Readers, authors, reviewers, and other stakeholders may report suspected misconduct to the editorial office, providing relevant information or supporting evidence.
All concerns will be handled fairly and confidentially, with appropriate protection for individuals reporting suspected misconduct in good faith.
10. Commitment to Publication Ethics
By submitting a manuscript, authors confirm that they have read and agreed to comply with the journal's publication ethics and AI-use policies.
By accepting an editorial or peer-review assignment, editors and reviewers agree to uphold confidentiality, impartiality, professional responsibility, and academic integrity. In particular, peer reviewers acknowledge and agree to the journal's strict prohibition on the use of AI to conduct, assist with, or generate any part of the peer-review process.
The journal reserves the right to revise this policy when necessary to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, research ethics, and publication standards. The current policy will be publicly available on the journal's website.
